I probably misunderstood previously. ProfileMatic does not quite work as I think you wished it would work:

When "Default rule" is triggered, it will set-up whatever has been specified in that rule (unless some other rule has set the specific action). It has nothing to do with what user has set in the Settings. ProfileMatic does not (and probably can not) detect what the user has done in the Settings application. If you want some settings that are applied always when no other rule matches, then you must explicitly put them into the Default rule.

The other thing is the working of the "restore previous". I'm not sure, but are you hitting this kind of scenariio. I'm using time based condition as an example as it's easy to understand.

- Initial profile: Ringing 60%
- 10:00 - 11:00: Set beep, restore previous
- 11:00 - 12:00: Set silent, restore previous

Now after 12:00, do you expect the profile to be Ringing 60% because that was the initial profile? The way ProfileMatic works, is that it will be beep. That's because before the last rule before setting to silent the profile was beep, so that's what is restored.